anime 7
manga 9
the anime has too many crappy moments of animation, filler arc etc
manga is great the art is way better then the anime and less crap
naruto is still one of my favorites among many others like HXh, Bleach, Hajime no Ippo but Naruto could've been a lot better
im finding this show a lot more childish and less enjoyable then when i first started watching it, occasionally when they show real ninjas on a mission (this only happens in explainations, and i think has only been shown twice) where they have to assassinate someone or get some information and they are all dressed in black and slaughter anyone in their way i get excited cos thats how i feel this anime show be more orientated, if not full hardcore like that then at least give it a bit of a darker edge, cos this unfortunately is really starting to feel like pokemon or something
undecided what rating to give it, but its over 6 ill say that much
Overall, I give Naruto an 8 maybe an 8.5.
And Jing is right, but IMO, if Naruto gets a 5, then FMA gets atleast a 20(yes its that good).
basey, u have to rememebr this wa snever meant to be a hardcore ninja show....the point of the show is to show the development of the kids, and as far as that goes, i think they've pulled it off nicely.
i do agree that it lacks those crazy ninja moments that we all love, but like i said, they never intended for the show to be like that in the first place.
personally, im loving the current arc, with the genins chasing teh sound nins thru the forest. the only thing equal to this was the zabuza arc. more stuff like this, and naruto is a 10 in my book. but currently its sitting at 8.
i think half the excitement is watching the whole thing happen at once, rather then waiting a week for each ep. thats probably y i enjoyed the zabuza arc more, cuz i watched lke the first 20 eps all at once.
you people are giving FMA too much credit it's not all that great, i'm not saying it's bad either but to me it was just a 7,5-8 nothing more nothing less i enjoyed it but you people are acting like it's some kind of holy show given to us by god
FMA rocked, I cant understand why you people give Naruto such high scores..
Storyline = almost none present
Animation= crap
Music = ok
Character depth = soso , depends on the char. Many flat-chars around the main-chars.
Athmosphere = 20% thrilling, 80% crap
I really dont get above 5/10
Also, many of you have only seen Naruto I think oO
http://wowsphere.com/concept6.jpg
Working on my future Warhammer Online journal, criticism demanded. Yes it's supposed to be that size.
not everthing can be fma great... which breaks the 12 on a 10 point scale. but the storyline of naruto is very clear, its heading in a single direction, although it can be overly predictalbe which is what ranks gantz and fma well above this. i do agree about the comment on flat characters. it really annoys me how many useless characters are floating around
my artwork : http://rasendori.deviantart.com/
sorry to break it to the FMAddicts, but FMA's only about half as great as you guys make it sound
it had a really interesting storyline, but its not the kind of series that i would watch again after seeing the conclusion
and ?igma, good thing you arent a critic, cause you cant judge character depth worth shit [img]i/expressions/face-icon-small-smile.gif[/img]
10/4/04 - 8/20/07
lol...assertn is rite, fma was a great show, but not somethign id watch over again. naruto, u can watch over several times.
if u want godly shows, then u have kenshin (up till the shishio arc) and trigun.
speaking of kenshin, can someone hook me u with the 2nd kenshin ova? and a dvdrip of the 1st one if possible
people are really biased to what they see/read first. i bet if one of you guys that say the manga is better than the anime watch any anime before reading its manga, youll like the anime better.
edit: my rating of naruto is a 9.4
I saw the anime first (up to the Gaara vs Lee battle), I still prefer the manga though. It has a more adult feel to it (considering all the censored scenes). So in my case, you are mistaken.Originally posted by: Zoels
people are really biased to what they see/read first. i bet if one of you guys that say the manga is better than the anime watch any anime before reading its manga, youll like the anime better.
edit: my rating of naruto is a 9.4
Respect the joindate, not the postcount ;P
www.anime-supreme.comOriginally posted by: Assassin
lol...assertn is rite, fma was a great show, but not somethign id watch over again. naruto, u can watch over several times.
if u want godly shows, then u have kenshin (up till the shishio arc) and trigun.
speaking of kenshin, can someone hook me u with the 2nd kenshin ova? and a dvdrip of the 1st one if possible
I'd have to say ?igma and a couple others are giving FMA way too much credit. Maybe it's just me, but the first episode of FMA didn't get to me as much as the first episode of Naruto. Naruto is the show that really dragged me into this fansub-anime genre. Before I was just watching whatever dubbed show on TV, but Naruto changed all of that. When I watched FMA a couple months ago I was just like "Meh, pretty good, nothing to boast about though".
Oh, and Naruto's music is way better than FMA's, with the exception of the first opening (dunno the name, it ends with Scar walking forward)
I would give Naruto a 9 its defintly not the most original show i've ever seen but it improves upon the typical anime sterotype.
Originally posted by: BOARD_of_command
www.anime-supreme.comOriginally posted by: Assassin
lol...assertn is rite, fma was a great show, but not somethign id watch over again. naruto, u can watch over several times.
if u want godly shows, then u have kenshin (up till the shishio arc) and trigun.
speaking of kenshin, can someone hook me u with the 2nd kenshin ova? and a dvdrip of the 1st one if possible
I'd have to say ?igma and a couple others are giving FMA way too much credit. Maybe it's just me, but the first episode of FMA didn't get to me as much as the first episode of Naruto. Naruto is the show that really dragged me into this fansub-anime genre. Before I was just watching whatever dubbed show on TV, but Naruto changed all of that. When I watched FMA a couple months ago I was just like "Meh, pretty good, nothing to boast about though".
Oh, and Naruto's music is way better than FMA's, with the exception of the first opening (dunno the name, it ends with Scar walking forward)
yeah i guess i'd have to agree i woulnd't say FMA is perfect, but to me its alot better than Naruto. and yes i also agree with you that Naruto's first episode was alot better than Fma's first episode. i almost wanted to cry on the first ep of naruto =P, but however things went downhill after haku saga -_-"
anime- 8
manga-9.5
you didnt get me, it wasnt about FMA, compared to other anime FMA also isnt THAT great. but it still rocks naruto.
Good thing I'm always a critic, b/c I can REALLY see the difference between flat-chars and round-chars.
http://wowsphere.com/concept6.jpg
Working on my future Warhammer Online journal, criticism demanded. Yes it's supposed to be that size.
Said by the guy with the avatar of a vampire who's only role in his particular series was to shoot random heads off.
Originally posted by: Terracosmo
Said by the guy with the avatar of a vampire who's only role in his particular series was to shoot random heads off.
10/4/04 - 8/20/07
The song is "Melissa" by Porno Graffiti.Originally posted by: BOARD_of_command
Oh, and Naruto's music is way better than FMA's, with the exception of the first opening (dunno the name, it ends with Scar walking forward)
edit: Also, ROCKS is a terrible song.
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote
