i give it a perfect score, its by far my favorite anime made
i give it a perfect score, its by far my favorite anime made
7 out of 10
[quote]
Originally posted by: mage
Originally posted by: losernin
For instance, why do the characters have light reflections on their forhead protectors with shadows on parts of their body inside the mud dome when it should be completely black? Same for Neji when hes wrapped up in that spider web in 115. Your guess is as good as mine. Usually the characters look like they've just been pasted onto the background without any skill at all, it's sickening.
Overall: 7.5
Well if you want to get technical, something reflective like their forehead protectors only reflects light. The only time it would be black would be if it's pitch black. Now I don't know if you think they were fighting in the dark but that doesn't look like case in either situation. This is also related to shadows on the body. If there is light, there has to be shadows.
In any case, I'd have to disagree. Naruto has a creative style to its animation. I've never seen animation quite like it.
I think someone needs to watch more anime...Originally posted by: y4but
Well if you want to get technical, something reflective like their forehead protectors only reflects light. The only time it would be black would be if it's pitch black. Now I don't know if you think they were fighting in the dark but that doesn't look like case in either situation. This is also related to shadows on the body. If there is light, there has to be shadows.
In any case, I'd have to disagree. Naruto has a creative style to its animation. I've never seen animation quite like it.
omfg i KNOW...Originally posted by: y4but
For instance, why do the characters have light reflections on their forhead protectors with shadows on parts of their body inside the mud dome when it should be completely black? Same for Neji when hes wrapped up in that spider web in 115. Your guess is as good as mine. Usually the characters look like they've just been pasted onto the background without any skill at all, it's sickening.
its like.....why didnt they make 3/4 of that episode just be pitch black with audio?
10/4/04 - 8/20/07
I think the whole idea is to encourage realism, and I'd think realism is better in animation, don't you? So.. you're telling me to watch more crappy anime to comply with your opinion. That's a great philosophy.
You don't seem to comprehend what is being said here.... The cave should have had no light in it, we agree that would have been stupid to sit there and watch a pitch black area and just have sound. They made it so you could see to prevent bordem however that does not mean that the forhead protectors should have been reflecting light all over the place.Originally posted by: y4but
I think the whole idea is to encourage realism, and I'd think realism is better in animation, don't you? So.. you're telling me to watch more crappy anime to comply with your opinion. That's a great philosophy.
i cant believe you guys are making a big deal over a strip of light grey and a strip of dark grey color over the forehead protectors in the dome
10/4/04 - 8/20/07
Do you not watch live action movies or anything? Even in dark scenes there is light refracting/reflecting all over the place. In the cave scene, the artists more than likely drew up the sequence as though it were live action and forhead protectors reflected light around as any metal would in a scene filmed in the dark.Originally posted by: Jessper
You don't seem to comprehend what is being said here.... The cave should have had no light in it, we agree that would have been stupid to sit there and watch a pitch black area and just have sound. They made it so you could see to prevent bordem however that does not mean that the forhead protectors should have been reflecting light all over the place.Originally posted by: y4but
I think the whole idea is to encourage realism, and I'd think realism is better in animation, don't you? So.. you're telling me to watch more crappy anime to comply with your opinion. That's a great philosophy.
The anime 7/10 the manga 8.5/10
The story is the weekest part in both manga and anime cause its predictable 70% of tíme. In HXH who is like Naruto isnt so predictable.
In the beggining before i saw HXH,FMA, and i thougt Naruto was 9.5 or even 10 but those showes showed what they had that was missing in Naruto. So Jing is right if FMA is 15 or even 20 if Naruto is a 10[img]i/expressions/face-icon-small-wink.gif[/img]
10/10
I love the complexity of the show and depth of personality in each unique character. Music owns too.
Well, the thing about Naruto is that it seems a lil childish for me. I suppose that at some points, the characters and such can either be too predictable or just plain ridiculous. Heh, guess this is why I prefer Bleach over Naruto.
I give it a 10. Not gonna say it's my favorite animes, cause I have lots of favorites, but it is a very good one. I like that the don't only focus on the main character but spread out the story between the rest as good as it does (atleast a lot of the time, anyway).
And Jing, very impressive work with those wallpapers, I'm using the second Neji one you posted now (the one that shows his specs and all that).
anime 7.5 manga 8
its very adictive and the naruto world has a lot of posibilities for new arcs. For those who rate it with a 2, i must say that i would never ever see such a bad anime and it seems u watch it(u need to watch to rate) so... 2 options: ur retard and watch a fucking shit anime (like 115 eps of garbage) or it deserves more than a 2.
Bye.
The path of excess leads to the tower of wisdom
OH Damn didnt know anyone actually used them =P, maybe ill make more now.Originally posted by: ZakuHan
I give it a 10. Not gonna say it's my favorite animes, cause I have lots of favorites, but it is a very good one. I like that the don't only focus on the main character but spread out the story between the rest as good as it does (atleast a lot of the time, anyway).
And Jing, very impressive work with those wallpapers, I'm using the second Neji one you posted now (the one that shows his specs and all that).
I give it a 7. Plain and simple. Too much shitty filler, too much cheap animation, and the show isn't anything to original, it just takes a concept of fighting animes and makes it very enjoyable and entertaining. The story is pretty shallow too, though well written, it isn't very deep, which is just fine for a long running series. All the flaws can be accepted because it's a good series still and such flaws are expected in 100 episode and more series.
8.
I'm really not that fond of the animation, and find it extremely sloppy at times. However, I simply love the storylines, the only exception here being the idiotic filler arc which was utterly useless. The music is simply put perfect. The show also offers an extremely rich character gallery. I don't think I've ever gotten attached to the characters in any anime as much as in Naruto, the only possible exception here being FMA and/or HxH. All in all it's a really good show that offers plenty of entertainment to me.
/ No, you warrant no villain's exposition from me.
Storyline: 8,5 .... depends on what arc is on. Now it's very good!
Graphics: 6,5 .... man I wish the animators from FMA were working on naruto, the animation vary's too much and most of the time it's below average compared to other anime's.
Music: 9,5 .... great music, bring out a new OST with the nice tracks damnit!!
Manga: 7 .... maybe i'm a noob manga reader. But sometimes i can't even follow what is happening. So I stopped reading the manga. And it's not as entertaining as the anime without music and such. Luckily I don't know anything what is going to happen in this arc [img]i/expressions/face-icon-small-smile.gif[/img].
Overall: 9 .... It's the only anime that's interesting now.
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote