The 3rd person who has it

[Fr0sT]

there could be another possibility....heres my theory

that the only way to beat mangekyou sharigan, is someone who can use mangekyou sharigan, so what if itachi was in a stale mate with the other "user" and the battle was not going anywhere, so one tries to escape,(so if itachi was the escapee) and not wanting to admit a loss, itachi just said he killed every1 to give him a superior reputation, and no1 question about remaining survivors. thats just my input.

or itachi wasnt the escapee and wasnt worried about the other user and considered him dead as hes no threat

[Raven]

Originally posted by: Fr0sT
there could be another possibility....heres my theory

that the only way to beat mangekyou sharigan, is someone who can use mangekyou sharigan, so what if itachi was in a stale mate with the other "user" and the battle was not going anywhere, so one tries to escape,(so if itachi was the escapee) and not wanting to admit a loss, itachi just said he killed every1 to give him a superior reputation, and no1 question about remaining survivors. thats just my input.

or itachi wasnt the escapee and wasnt worried about the other user and considered him dead as hes no threat

Itachi doesn't seem like the lying type to me. He has honour - I don't think he'd lie about how many people he's killed. It's all about the glory of battle, warriors take these things very seriously, they'd rather die than be dishonest about it.

[Superman]

Originally posted by: CmDr_RavEn
Itachi doesn't seem like the lying type to me. He has honour - I don't think he'd lie about how many people he's killed. It's all about the glory of battle, warriors take these things very seriously, they'd rather die than be dishonest about it.

When did Itachi become a Klingon? There is no substance behind this claim. Itachi killed his whole family, even his old grandparents. There is no honor in killing someone obviously weaker than you for no reason.

[Mut]

Originally posted by: Superman

Originally posted by: CmDr_RavEn
Itachi doesn't seem like the lying type to me. He has honour - I don't think he'd lie about how many people he's killed. It's all about the glory of battle, warriors take these things very seriously, they'd rather die than be dishonest about it.

When did Itachi become a Klingon? There is no substance behind this claim. Itachi killed his whole family, even his old grandparents. There is no honor in killing someone obviously weaker than you for no reason.

he meant that even though itach is ruthless, he is still able to keep his word and not lie about crap like that... why would someone like itachi need to lie about killing x amount of people? he can kick anyone ass right now.