The 3rd person who has it

[Mut]

Originally posted by: Superman

Originally posted by: CmDr_RavEn
Itachi doesn't seem like the lying type to me. He has honour - I don't think he'd lie about how many people he's killed. It's all about the glory of battle, warriors take these things very seriously, they'd rather die than be dishonest about it.

When did Itachi become a Klingon? There is no substance behind this claim. Itachi killed his whole family, even his old grandparents. There is no honor in killing someone obviously weaker than you for no reason.

he meant that even though itach is ruthless, he is still able to keep his word and not lie about crap like that... why would someone like itachi need to lie about killing x amount of people? he can kick anyone ass right now.

[Jman]

^Agrees with the above post

[viciousHyuuga]

think the 3rd one could be kakashi .. cause itachi would of known about kakashi an probarly would of known who he got his eye off, considering it was a past flashback i dont think at that time itachi thought he could own kakashi.
-
-
dosnt make sence the 3rd uchiha would of been out of town, an what he didnt come back? cause we would of known of him by now, or im sure the 3rd would of known he was on a mission or something. unless he was working together with itachi an his hiding.

but then again im talking on logic, in anime logic dosnt always count =)

[xtort]

I could not be Kakashi, as Kakashi only has the eye, not the blood. Hence "Blood Line Limit." Did anyone notice that Inane's scanslation said "three who are able," not "three who have it" ?? Are there any other scanslations that use more precise verbiage? I can tell of two meanings: that there are three people who possess the ABILITY to get Mangekyo, or that there are three people (once Sasuke has attained it) who know how to use it?? The wording is imprecise and could mean either.

-xtortout

[realtortato]

Hey, but what if it's Naruto?
I mean we know absolutly nothing about his parents, except that Yondaime might be his father.
And what if he was going around banging an Uchiha woman.
I mean who knows?
What if Sausgay discovers that Naruto is his cousin and Shoots himself for having such an "idiot" in his family. I would certainly like to see that happen, lol.
If that's the case maybe that is the reason why Itachi told Kisame (After the fight in the hotel with Jiraiya) he wanted to wait until something about Naruto happened before kidnapping him.

[viciousHyuuga]

hahahah now that i would like to see.

if that is the case fuk naruto is equal to god. haha


-- to my understanding itachi said including myself there are three who can handle the mangekyou. now considering it was a flashback. it could be possible he was including kakashi. he didnt say another uchiha.

[Mut]

it's not possible cuz only uchihas can awaken the mangekyou sharingan... that's why only another uchiha can defeat itachi.

EDIT:

what do you mean mayb so. are you thinking that there is some other possibility that the 3rd person with the mangekyou sharingan isn't an uchiha?

[viciousHyuuga]

maybe so.

[Uchiha Barles]

I'm guessing he means that the mangekyou sharingan isn't necessarily as undefeatable as itachi is claiming it is, and that it's possible that someone can find a way to defeat the technique and/or itachi. It's the only interpretation that makes any sense.

[originalkrn]

even though "3 may be able to have it" means that 3 people may have the ability to use it pretty much suggests that there will be another person in the manga that can use the ability. Why would kishimoto write that if it had no significance? If no one other than Sasuke and Itachi would actually possess the power? I am pretty sure it will not be Kakashi, but it just might, you never know. I hope its an uchiha girl that gets it.

[kAi]

my guess it is an uchiha in hiding..
goto chapter 224 and check out page 11..
the ninja on top of the telegraph pole that sasuke sees...
ive been looking at this picture and i dont think it is itachi...
it could be an uchiha and it could be the 3rd mangekyou sharingan user...
the reason why i dont think it is itachi his because the hair is too long to be itachis...and i dont think kishimoto has stuffed up by drawing the hair longer than it is supposed to be..the hair drawn will reach near the bottom of his back..while itachis goes down in between his shoulder blades..

[Reason]

It is probably Sasuke's Mother, and Itachi took the blame for killing everyone. We will have to wait and see, [img]i/expressions/face-icon-small-wink.gif[/img]

Whoever it is, they are probably the one that killed everyone, and to protect that person Itachi took the blame, and also this way the person would be assumed to be dead.

- Reason -

[jing]

They are just using sharingan contacts to scare people that's all.

[Mut]

Originally posted by: kAi
my guess it is an uchiha in hiding..
goto chapter 224 and check out page 11..
the ninja on top of the telegraph pole that sasuke sees...
ive been looking at this picture and i dont think it is itachi...
it could be an uchiha and it could be the 3rd mangekyou sharingan user...
the reason why i dont think it is itachi his because the hair is too long to be itachis...and i dont think kishimoto has stuffed up by drawing the hair longer than it is supposed to be..the hair drawn will reach near the bottom of his back..while itachis goes down in between his shoulder blades..

god... are you kidding me...? that's itachi, there is NO reason for us to think otherwrise.

[G-Pong]

zing for jing!

[calvin]

Uchiha Shisui
Killed by: Uchiha Itachi and made it look like a sucide
Manga: Ch.222, pg.4 *Mentioned*
A talented member of the Uchiha Clan he was found drowned in the Nakano River with a suicide note saying, Im tired of the duties, there is no future for Uchiha and for me I cannot walk out the path any further. However, many believe he wouldnt be the type of person who would just kill himself and anyone with a sharigan can copy his handwriting as well. So the Police Force are performing an investigation and they have their hunches that Itachi would be responsible. In fact later Itachi admits to killing his best-friend to reach a new level of sharigan

that solves everything. i think
taken from www.narutoinfo.com

[viciousHyuuga]

Originally posted by: kAi
my guess it is an uchiha in hiding..
goto chapter 224 and check out page 11..
the ninja on top of the telegraph pole that sasuke sees...
ive been looking at this picture and i dont think it is itachi...
it could be an uchiha and it could be the 3rd mangekyou sharingan user...
the reason why i dont think it is itachi his because the hair is too long to be itachis...and i dont think kishimoto has stuffed up by drawing the hair longer than it is supposed to be..the hair drawn will reach near the bottom of his back..while itachis goes down in between his shoulder blades..

-

i dont think it would be someone else. but the picture looks like the person up there has 3 swords, one on his back 2 on his side. while itachi has only one on his back.
-

but until i see another uchiha. im standing my ground on its just another power ninja who can handle it.
-
cause it could be a jutsu everyone can gain, but it just easyier for a uchiha to do it by killing there best friend.

[Mut]

Originally posted by: calvin
Uchiha Shisui
Killed by: Uchiha Itachi and made it look like a sucide
Manga: Ch.222, pg.4 *Mentioned*
A talented member of the Uchiha Clan he was found drowned in the Nakano River with a suicide note saying, Im tired of the duties, there is no future for Uchiha and for me I cannot walk out the path any further. However, many believe he wouldnt be the type of person who would just kill himself and anyone with a sharigan can copy his handwriting as well. So the Police Force are performing an investigation and they have their hunches that Itachi would be responsible. In fact later Itachi admits to killing his best-friend to reach a new level of sharigan

that solves everything. i think
taken from www.narutoinfo.com

hmmm, no. it doesn't solve anything. in ch 225, itachi talks about how there WILL be two more people who can awaken the mangekyou sharingan. shisui cannot be one of the two because he is dead already.

[kAi]

how isnt there another reason to think otherwise...
itachi has said that there is 3 people who can gain the mangekyou sharingan...
the hair is so much longer on the person on the pole than itachis...itachi has no reason to use henge...and looks like he has to extra weapons on his sides...from that position on the pole sasuke runs straight to where is parents are and itachi is inside the room waiting for him to return...why cant the possibility of it being someone else be true..?

dont get me wrong though it could be itachi...im just putting in a view that can be seen another way...

[Mut]

omg... are you coming up with the possibility that it could be someone else by judging the length of the hair??? are characters' hair lengths always the same in every drawing?

the way people think just amazes me sometimes. they ignore the common sense and logic and try to think of things that are impossible through overanalysis. this ranks up with the one about how kakashi learned kage bunshin no jutsu from naruto. just amazing.

EDIT: i really didn't want to be so harsh, i apologize. but if anyone can agree with you and provide more evidence that's more solid, please let me know.