Who had the roughest past?

[SK]

Naruto had just as bad a past as Gaara. The villagers hated and feared both of them. Gaara killed his mom, but Naruto never even knew of heard anything of his parents. I think both had a rough past the big difference is that Naruto could control the monster inside of him while Gaara coulden't. Gaara became a complete psycho when he got mad, and would lose control. Naruto never went psycho and tried to kill classmates, which allowed him to make friends, unlike Gaara. Both had a rough past, they just handled their situations differently.

[Tass]

thats because naruto found someone that didnt hate him though...if it wasnt for that, he might just have well turned out as bad as gaara.

humm...i wonder if he'd be able to control his demon though (without the friendship that Iruka Sensei gave him)...my guess would be yes, because unlike gaara, who was binded to his demon, Naruto is just a container for his. its sealed up so no "control" is actually nessicary. or am i mistaken?

[Feannag]

Shouldn't be any contest, has to be Gaara. While Naruto still was an outcast/orphan in time he had people who believed in him. Sasuke wasn't totally alone in that he had a purpose to guide him (being an avenger and killing Itachi) so depite lonliness he had that to hold onto.

Gaara on the other hand not only had neither, but what was done to him was completely unjustified. He never asked to be the ultimate ninja, and he never asked to have the Sand bound to his body. He was just a normal kid that wanted normal things, and then those were denied him. And then his whole world was completely shattered when he inadvertently killed Yashamaru and learned everything he was told by him (the only person Gaara thought cared about and loved him) was a complete and utter lie. And that shattered his mind and mutated him into the monster he is now.

There really shouldn't be any contest, as the poll shows.

[Feannag]

Originally posted by: -Sharingan-Kakashi-
Naruto had just as bad a past as Gaara. The villagers hated and feared both of them. Gaara killed his mom, but Naruto never even knew of heard anything of his parents. I think both had a rough past the big difference is that Naruto could control the monster inside of him while Gaara coulden't. Gaara became a complete psycho when he got mad, and would lose control. Naruto never went psycho and tried to kill classmates, which allowed him to make friends, unlike Gaara. Both had a rough past, they just handled their situations differently.

Actually I think the sealling involved in both of them were significantly different. Naruto's sealing was designed to be total and seperate. It wasn't intended for the Nine-Tails to actually interact with Naruto, it was done because a body is needed to house the Nine-Tails and Naruto was chosen from the 4ths scarifice.

Gaara, on the other hand, was sealed/bound with the intention of interaction. KazeKage intended to have the Sand interact with Gaara and protect him, to make him the ultimate ninja. The Sand had a more direct and tangible link on Gaara's being to give him the powers he has now. Gaara went insane not only from the deception but also from attempting to keep the Sand at bay and keep it from taking over.

[SK]

Naruto does have self control which was showed when he went psycho against Haku, when he was about to kill Haku, he stopped, and went back to normal. I'm sure if Naruto had decided to try and kill some of his classmates Iruka wouldent like him either...

[Karasu]

Gaara for obvious reasons.. I think Sasuke had a pretty rough past aswell.

Naruto sure he was hated and feared in someway but it didnt involve death and decay and betrayal and shit. But he sure had a tragic past aswell.

[Black_Challenger08]

I think it's hard to distinguish (for me) between Sasuke and Gaara...

[Rek]

Thats an interesting reason not to kill people... "I'd kill Sasuke, but then I'd get no Ramen"

[Click]

Gotta be Gaara, his past was as bad as it gets...

[deadlydreamx]

I would have to say sasuke because all your friends and relatives are all killed by your brother and then your left all by yourself to survive.

[iMUSTbeTHEdevil]

I think that Sasuke had a pretty rough life. He has to feel responsible for the death of his Clan. I mean Gaara had it bad....but Sasuke has to live everyday with the knowledge that MAYBE he could have changed things if only he was stronger. So Sasuke has alot of inner demons...and although they arent a Racoon Dog or a Nine Tail Fox...I think that Sasuke has it pretty bad!


[img]i/expressions/devil.gif[/img]

[Gama Oyabin]

gaara ofcourse..those flashbacks where really dramatic..

[Rek]

Originally posted by: deadlydreamx
I would have to say sasuke because all your friends and relatives are all killed by your brother and then your left all by yourself to survive.

'thanks... I'm glad someone is finally agreeing with me. ^.^


...and you too devil

[basey44]

gaara hands down
buts thats probably because in the flashbacks it shows his innocience (bad spelling i know) and how sad he is, sasuke was pretty bad as everyone he loved was killed, but it didnt warp him

[Feannag]

Originally posted by: -Sharingan-Kakashi-
Naruto does have self control which was showed when he went psycho against Haku, when he was about to kill Haku, he stopped, and went back to normal. I'm sure if Naruto had decided to try and kill some of his classmates Iruka wouldent like him either...

Yes, but the only reason he did stop was he had met Haku earlier unknowingly. It was the recognition after the mask broke that stopped him. Had it been a stranger he never met, he probably would have killed him

[SK]

And Garra didnt know his classmates?

[InnerSakuraChan]

Garra definatly had it worst - 1) everyone hates/ is afraid of him/ 2) his fater has tried to kill him 3) he can't kill himself 4) he was created out of hate 5) no one aknowledes his feelings, they look on him as a monster however, 6) everyone respects him out of fear

next naruto - 1) everyone hates/is afraid of him however, 2) no one has tried to kill him, and 3) he can kill himself if he wants to. 4) naruto, however was "created" out of love, for the village (4th's sacrifice). 5) most of is childhood, no one acknowledges him, but, now, naruto actually has friends 6) naruto gets no repect.

saske is a distant thrid. 1) no one hates him 2) no one has tried to kill him 3) he can kill himself 4) wan't "created". his abnormality (the sharringan) is respected 5) is aknowleded by the village as the heir to the uchiha clan 6) and is respected as such. besides, all the girls want him.

[High Wind]

Originally posted by: Konoha Rek
well, I was posting about this earlier, I just never made a poll... I think Sasuke...

It's kinda like some dude with wings coming up to you and saying, it must suck and you must hate your life because you don't have wings... but it really doesn't because
you've never had wings, so you have nothing to compare it too.

Naruto and Gaara never really had anyone, so its hard to compare. Which (believe me) totally sucks. But Sasuke had a family, a brother, a community... As I said, probably an entire village. Uchiha literally means Village of the Leaf. (Konoha means Of The Leaf) and he WITNESSED these peoples death...

A decent analogy would be being dropped on a bed of glass... all three were dropped on the same bed of glass, naruto was dropped, left there, then helped out. Gaara was dropped helped out a bit, then dropped back. Sasuke was about 3 stories up, then dropped on it, and rubbed into it everytime he gets in a fight that he might lose.

who do you think has it worst?

I Actually agree with this.

As of right now I have to say that Naruto probably had it easy compared to the rest.

As Rek mentioned, the others had no kind of happiness to compare their sorrow to, but Sasuke did

And Gaara... Thats like finding out that your Parents, Girlfriend/Boyfriend, or someone else you loved, has lied to you about everything, hates your guts, and wants to kill you... Just thinking about me being in a situation like that brings a chill down my spine