Boku no Hero Academia

[shinta|hikari]

I understand the logic behind that, but it makes more sense for her ability to be less OP than to have a mislabeled and mysterious stamina factor. It's already ridiculous that she can just heal anyone at anytime with no real consequence to her. Even genius surgeons and the like get tired. But I digress.

I wouldn't mind it if they simply said that her healing ability had other negative side effects period. They didn't need to rationalize it as the recipient dying because they got tired from healing too fast. And if they wanted to do that anyway, they need to stick with it and not let Izuku heal up the very next day.

Ryll's blood transfusion analogy makes sense if Izuku needed a few weeks or so to recover before being subjected to insta-heals again. Resting for one night and then being able to avoid death from exhaustion from the heals right after just feels lazy.

EDIT:
I remember Ryll mentioning something about the danger of over-explaining things in fiction in the Heavy Object thread. I think this falls into that category. Had they simply said that granny's heals were limited because you'll die, I'd have accepted that at face value because of all the supernatural stuff happening in this show. However, the moment they tried to explain it with pseudo-medical science, it becomes vulnerable to analysis.

Sure, I can just turn off my brain after seeing the inconsistency, but I try to avoid doing that with shows that I have a certain degree of respect and expectation for.

So, no, this show isn't really any worse because of this aspect. Minor issues like these simply stand out in above average stories, so I couldn't help but mention them.