Quote Originally Posted by shinta|hikari View Post
Not so sure about that. Eren has always been a hero. He's not the type to sacrifice people, especially those he cares for, for his goal. What he is totally ready to sacrifice is himself, which fits the hero archetype.

That's the main difference between Historia's and Eren's reactions to the bullshit story. Historia was asked to kill her friend to save humanity. Eren was asked to kill himself. Historia doing that may be practical but cruel. Eren doing that is heroic, coz yknow, he's the protagonist. His life is his own to spend. Historia doesn't have the right to kill him. That's the critical difference.
What he said. Plus: No matter what you claim, Darth, without Eren reacting unexpectedly, Historia wouldn't have snapped, wouldn't have returned to being a good person. That makes her a bitch in my book.