Naruto Chapter 510

[TwisT]

Is it just me or is this thread full of misinformation.

Long ago he said Hyuuga had spawned Uchiha when the eye mutated. Now he goes and say that Uchiha and Senju were once one and that thew spawned from the Sage of Six Paths.

This has been "proven" wrong long before. This is nothing new. Both the Hyuuga/Uchiha and the Sage-->Uchiha/Senju have been brought up at least 50-100 chapters ago.

And lo at the sudden revelation that Nagato was really an Uzumaki a along. A popular fan theory, when Pain was first introduced, was that he and Naruto were related. It was discarded some time later and now Kishimoto suddenly decided to pull it out of his ass and confirm it was true after all.

There was never anything in the manga to support that. At that time Yahiko-Pain had only been drawn in black and white and therefore had white hair. He kind of looked like Naruto with the spiky hair. That is where that theory came to be. Later it was said that Kushina was red haired and then fanpics of Yahiko-Pain with red hair showed up and it was on again. There was never a theory about Nagato-Pain as an Uzumaki. And Kishimoto never did anything to confirm or deny that claim. Also another thing is that i think when Jiraya and Tsunade talked before he left to fight Pain, they might have mentioned Kushina having a brother or something like that. But that last part I'm not sure about. It might just be me confusing someone's theory with cannon.

I'm confused. I thought Kabuto revived Nagato with his edo tensai? And to do that he needed the original body, how the hell is his body in that tomb as well? How does this make sense?

We never got to see who he revived. People only speculated since Madara/Tobi got surprised. One was that it was Nagato so he could get the eyes and someone to summon the statue. Some said it was Madara himself since many believe that Tobi isn't Madara, and by summoning the real Madara he had to cave in. Some said it was the forth or Senju since they have both beaten Madara and he would fear them. Further Edo Tensei never needed the body of the summoned. This was stated during Oro/Sarutobi fight. It was both stated by the ANBU captain who watched that it was not really them, and Sarutobi answered by saying "I know". Later when they died (or something like that) they all turned out too be the Sound nins that hunted Naruto & Co in the second Chunin exam. Basically it used another body to summon the spirit of whoever you wanted to resurrect.

Rewritten story

Kubo, is that you??? :P

[Sidnne]

We never got to see who he revived. People only speculated since Madara/Tobi got surprised. One was that it was Nagato so he could get the eyes and someone to summon the statue. Some said it was Madara himself since many believe that Tobi isn't Madara, and by summoning the real Madara he had to cave in.

No, Kabuto revived the fallen Akatsuki members, including Nagato.

Chapter 489 pg 18, and also http://www.9panels.com/manga/naruto/#issue/490/

[FelixZeroAlastor]

No, Kabuto revived the fallen Akatsuki members, including Nagato.

Chapter 489 pg 18, and also http://www.9panels.com/manga/naruto/#issue/490/

Well no one really explained how that Jutsu works. I really doubt that Kabuto could have found Itachi's body from right under Madara's nose. No, it would make more sense if he really just need something from them to create a new body for them. Like a shadow body. If I remember correctly, when the Third defeated the First and Second it was revealed that their bodies were really the two who lost during the exam. correct me if I'm wrong. So in essence the bodies, including Nagato, are merely shadows of their counterparts. (On a side note I think Kabuto has the actual Sage of Six Paths in his last box.)

About the Hyuuga and Uchiha thing. Well history can be faked. Also the whole Madara giving giving Nagato the Rinnengan isn't so far fetched anymore. He probably killed his parents and needed a young Uzumaki to awaken the eyes that he stole from someone else.

[animus]

This has been "proven" wrong long before. This is nothing new. Both the Hyuuga/Uchiha and the Sage-->Uchiha/Senju have been brought up at least 50-100 chapters ago.

It proved nothing. It's called blatant retconning, because terrible author is terrible.