Originally Posted by
Buffalobiian
I was initially put off by Wolverine too, but I revised my opinion after some thought. I'm not really interested in an animated film that looks like animated frames from a Marvel comic book. To quote what I was expecting:
Did Ironman look good?
Yeah, it was visually pleasing.
Did it look familiar?
Yeah, it's like I was watching the Ironman movie animated.
Could I tell if it was Marvel or a Japanese studio that made it?
No. Convince me that Marvel couldn't have done it in a high budget American studio that didn't borrow anything "anime".
From what I saw, you could scratch out Bold and Tradition of Japan. I saw nothing Japanese in that. I'm all open for how animation techniques differ between Japanese and Western studios, but the most defining thing that puts anime apart from other forms of animation is the art style. What happened to being "redesigned"?
Sure, Wolverine looks off, but at least they're living up to being bold and redesigning him. They didn't get it quite right, and I'm all too happy to that out. After all, no body learns to walk right from the get go.
Ironman chose to walk the safe zone. It's all too familiar and is nothing groundbreaking like they're making it out to be.