Quote Originally Posted by Pandadice
but, i must say that when Battler and Beatrice popped up in the chapel, in the paused-mode where they discuss the happenings, i think i finally got whats going on. and now i'm interested.. only.. i guess i might be a little interested, but i more just really hate Battler now as a character, for being so stupid and stubborn...
You give up way too easily to the witch. All of the murders so far have been pretty easy to prove without magic. Hardly anybody has alibis during most of them. Especially that there is an extra person running around on the island.

You just have to assume that the magical scenes are not actually quite what happened. The witch obviously isn't going to show you the true scene, because then she would be disproved!