One Piece 338

[Assertn]

I think they also neglected to mention that, to elaborate on Sanji calling it a half-curse, now that Brooke has already been revived, he no longer enjoys the benefit of being a devils fruit user, yet still carries the weakness to sea water.

Assuming he can't be revived a 3rd time, anyway.

[Death13a]

Since Brooke came back as soul does it mean devil fruit give power to soul and not to body?

And Brooke still enjoys his power since he probably doesn't age anymore (he spend 10 years as skeleton and didn't changed). And technically you can't kill a skeleton so the question is will he 'die' if dropped in water or will he simple be paralyzed until rescued?

[Assertn]

And Brooke still enjoys his power since he probably doesn't age anymore (he spend 10 years as skeleton and didn't changed). And technically you can't kill a skeleton so the question is will he 'die' if dropped in water or will he simple be paralyzed until rescued?

But is this an ability he gained as a result of the fruit, or as a result of him being a skeleton?
In other words, if he found his body right away before it decomposed, would he lose that ability?

so many questions.....

[DarthEnderX]

It is a puzzle.

I'm going to, for now, assume that the fruit is still in effect and if he "dies" again(somehow, dunno how a skeleton can die) that his soul would return to his body again.

I have no evidence of this, but I can't see why a fruit would have a one-time only effect.