Hi

I am working on a poster for my boyfriend's birthday. FMA is his favorite anime, and I have only JUST started watching it (up to ep 12).

I am doing a preliminary photoshop pic, and then I am basically going to duplicate it in Illustrator after so the poster can be resizeable to any size and still be crisp (im turning it into a vector drawing).

So I have already started some of the work, so I will upload a few of the WIPs. The first pic is my sketch on the right and the references i used on the left.

What I am wondering is what composition do you guys prefer?

Just ed, ed with al, or ed with al and the alchemy circle off center?

I seem to prefer just ed, but it feels empty .