I really don't like stories that has slow plot development but in this, i might try to watch stuff like this again.
I really don't like stories that has slow plot development but in this, i might try to watch stuff like this again.
I think the reason red garden has such a small fanbase is because it tried so many things different, such as the art, the singing, the setting, the characters, and maybe even the story all at the same time. A lot of people are put off if they find something completely alien to them.
Peace.
Yet, they are the first ones to complain when the anime they're watching is full of clichés and "rip-offs". I myself find that this is a very very good series. The only down side, I'd say is the amount of dialogue, it's too much at times and repititive. Luckily, I find most of the character insteractions very good, so I don't mind it much... the series could've used a bit of more action, like what we saw in episode 16, it was awesome.Originally Posted by shinta|hikari
Well, I've finally caught up after putting the series on hold for a while JC and Lula could've used more screen time, at least Lula still have a chance to show more appearances. And I want Paula to hurry up and get all lesbian with Kate, and finally reveal any secrets that are left if any. Four more episodes to go, hopefully they'll be good. I think that this will have a very sad ending regardless, but I know it will be a satisfying one with few plot holes remaining and loose ends.
Just caught up with this one, it's been very interesting so far. I'm not sure if it's cliché or not since I don't usually watch whatever genre this show counts as but I like most of the charachters and I like the way they interact and the show feels real to me. I do wish there was more action, however the stuff in ep 16 seemed to come out of nowhere and I didn't like that, since most everything else in the show was been decently explained. The Blonde Brotherhood (my name for the Hervé faction) guys having the super jump powers felt like it came out of nowhere.
The girls and their issues are similar to WB show charachters with powers like Buffy or Clark Kent. It's interesting to see a Japanese take on that archetype, and Red Garden has been much more interesting outside the 'powers' than either of those shows were to me initially (likely due to the lack of the 'freak of the week' system the generally plagues that type of show in its first few seasons).
I know most of you guys finished the series already, but I just watched episode 19.
So the other policeman got shot also. I thought that he would live a little longer, man those policemen wasted their time for nothing. So, it seems like Herme will have no choice but to try and save Kate, for his sister's sake and I think he may have a little bit of afection at least. But damnit, they keep teasing me with the lesbian actions and now that Kate was caught, I think that the president of Grace is going to become rash and try to save her and die in the process... the thought of it is pissing me off.
Nice series overall. Story was quite intriguing form episode one ‘till the end, but got to say that its execution could have been done better, especially towards the end. Character development was great and the best part of the show, imo. You clearly can see the changes the characters undergo as they interact with each other during the whole series. I found them likeable and quite interesting. As far animation goes, I have to say I was really pleased. Consistence was kept form episode to episode and battles went smooth and were well presented.
About the ending itself, I would say it was alright. It gave the sensation of completeness at least. However, it could have been better. I felt that the explanation about the curse was quite uninteresting and rushed, as well its final resolution. The level of drama wasn’t as good as previous episodes (ex: ep.1 and ep.16) (imo, the last episodes of an action/thriller/romance series should have the best drama of all). I also wasn’t that impress about the fight between the two bands as well the death of some of the characters (they just died like regular BG characters…well at least that was the feeling I got)
Even though all that, I have to say the series was fun to watch ‘till the end. No regrets whatsoever.
I actually thought that the drama in the final episode was very good. The scenes with Herve and his dying sister were extraordinary, and even though Lula died, she pretty much giving Herve one of the blows that killed him was, in my opinion, a nice detail. I also thought that the 4 girls going to sleep while Lise was talking about how she's found love as she disappeared was a nice touch too.
I do agree with you that the curse explanation felt rushed. But, there's an OVA coming up, and some of these questions and complaints we have might be resolved in the OVA.
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote
