Yeah to much information to assimilate, too much plot dev to have the usual plot dev impact.
It's lost it's rarety, so it's not good anymore.
You get gold necklace, the day after you hear on the radio that water can be turned into gold on a 1:1 ratio.
Gold rarety lost, gold is shit thus your beloved necklace is shit.

Thats the way I see it, they poured too much dev, it's lost a good part of it's value, thus the show lost it's value.
For me, BSG shot itself in the foot.