I'd like to take part in the voting. I think Kage and Eurasian should vote too, since the 3 of us are eliminated participants.
If three's not enough, you can bring in more.
How does that sound?
I'd like to take part in the voting. I think Kage and Eurasian should vote too, since the 3 of us are eliminated participants.
If three's not enough, you can bring in more.
How does that sound?
That's a great idea. Personally, I think it would be good to have a few different categories that you can give a score to for each under each category, and the highest score moves on. This would avoid a deadlock of each judge voting for a different sig, and would encourage you guys to evaluate the sigs more critically.
Liquid Echo officially has until Thursday morning, 9:00am (Ontario time) to show up.
Originally posted by: KitKat
Sounds good to me. We can appoint a few impartial judges, and move on accordingly.
I LIKE JUDGING! lol, and i was going to sign up but phoenix took this sig outta heaven and gave it to me so now i dont need one...acctually i should rotate colors again [img]i/expressions/face-icon-small-happy.gif[/img]. anyway, the point of this post was, i'll judge if its not a problem with the contestants.
LaZie made this...a long time ago.
"It was a very depressing time in my life, since I had no money I was unable to screw the rules" -Kaiba
kOriginally posted by: GLS
I'd like to take part in the voting. I think Kage and Eurasian should vote too, since the 3 of us are eliminated participants.
If three's not enough, you can bring in more.
How does that sound?
I like the idea of Kage, Eurasian and GLS voting.
Yeah, sounds good. Well back to homework -_-
Oh, and I made the bleach sig [img]i/expressions/face-icon-small-wink.gif[/img]
Yeah, congrats Koyuki, you move on to the final round!
Alright, it's Thursday night, and the Liquid Echo sigs are now open for voting by our fabulous judges: Kage, Eurasian, and GLS. Please try to give a critical analysis of each of the sigs and then give your choice. Back up your choice with concrete reasons. Since you guys are artists, the 'It looks nice' reason doesn't cut it [img]i/expressions/face-icon-small-tongue.gif[/img]
/me avoids the American Idol reference
Sig #1: This sig is pretty darn cool. It looks as if they took a stock photo of a winter scene, and put it to use on both sides of Sasuke. The blur added to Sasuke is really cool, and the scanlines help out as well. This sig features the best use of a render. Also has the best avatar of the trio.
Sig #2: At first glance, I didn't think much of this sig. After looking at it more, it's really interesting, and demands attention with its vibrant colors. The render was cleaned up pretty well, and the text formatting is good, imo (I'm not quite sold on the color, though). I would've preferred the avatar to feature Tayuya, rather than a fragment of the sig.
Sig #3: This sig could've been better, imo. The render is too small to be clearly seen (with the new size dimensions allowed, it could possibly be improved), and the ripple effect doesn't fit well. More tech-style brushing like in the bottom left corner would've been cool.
So... you skipped my boring, subpar analysis, eh? You really don't care what I think. You'd rather know who I voted for.
Both #1 and #2 are good sigs. If #2's avatar featured Tayuya, I'd vote #2 easily rather than pondering my decision.
I will give my vote to... #2, because it's one of the most unique sigs in this tournament. If I were Liquid Echo, I'd 1) be here to participate and 2) rotate both these sigs, since they are both cool.
Now... read my analysis!
Hang on a second... what do we do if its a three way tie?
I was under the impression that we were to use some kind of scoring, say 3points for #1 2points for #2 and 1point for #3. The sig with most points goes through.
Yeah, let's do it that way. And after that if there's a tie in number of points, we can bring in NM as the tie-breaker since he's the most recent one to be out of the competition.
If we're going to do it this way, than my scoring is pretty much self-explanatory.Originally posted by: PSJ
I was under the impression that we were to use some kind of scoring, say 3points for #1 2points for #2 and 1point for #3. The sig with most points goes through.
Sig 2: 3 points
Sig 1: 2 points
Sig 3: 1 point
So... when was the deadline for the voting again?
No idea, the whole fanart section has felt a bit dead for some time now.
We are waiting for Kage and Eurasian to vote now, perhaps it might be time to send them a PM? Though I guss since KitKat is incharge of this, it would be better if she was the one who sent the PM's.
Ack I'm sorry guys, I thought you weren't gonna be doing one for me, so wasn't paying attention. Sorry to hold it up like that. All of you did a great job, but I've decided to go with this one. I really liked the image AND my name is nice and visible... Thanks much!
Ok, Kittie your call, what do we do?
where are the sigs I need to judge?
Your too late... Liquid Echo came back and chose his sig... the judging was only supposed to take place if he didn't pick one.
Finally! Alright, even though this contest seems to be inching along, we've reached the final stage!
We'll continue as originally planned, now that Liquid Echo has returned. I know for a fact that DB will be around for the conclusion of this contest, so there will be no more delays.
Congratulations to Koyuki and Phoenix for making it to the final round! Gentlemen, you have exactly one week to produce an awesome sig for DB. And, just as an added bonus, there may be a custom title for the winner. It's still under negotiation, but it's a definite possibility. The exact title is a secret for now. I'll keep you updated on the details.
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote
