it's not like Talia didn't want to be with Gil any more
more that she couldn't be with him anymore because she wanted to have a child
and yes it all is unexplained but that has been that way since Seed
in that aspect they loyally follow the example of Seed, even though it's a bad example in that case
Love is fiction, misery is my only friend
I would appriciate it if next time you have a problem with a post, you conduct yoursefl with a little more civility. The fact is that that's the way I interperated that scene and the followup scenes so it's what I assumed to be right; I _was_ wrong, but there are better was to go about telling someone that rather than calling it all 'bullshit'.Originally posted by: PSJ
That sounds like bs to me. Give me a reference to where that is said. Sounds like something you just made up on your own.
Anyway, having bothered to watch the episode again I can still see why I made the assumption, but that's not really the point. It seems that PLANT has rules about couplings (without knowing what they are we I can't elaborate) and Talia and dillundal were not a match, so she leaves him for someone else who is a match - to which Dillundal replies, "Who made the decision, and what was it?".
It seems Dillundal has/had problems with the meaning his existance and wants to create a world where everyone has a purpose and no one is stuck of trivialised paths.
I'll take a stabbing guess and say that Rey is the illigitimate son of Talia and either Dillundal (unlikely) or Rau, though the guy she walks off with in the flashback clearly isn't him - but Rey still bears striking similarities to Talia (when he's younger, he has her hair shape and eyes, though grown up he looks much more like Rau, with obvious differences.) Though neither probably know they are related. It struck me as interesting that Rey was locked away in a dark room for no defineable purpose and Rau kinda 'saved' him.
If you by Edited mean the episode where Gil has his flashbacks about Talia, then that's the one I'm using as reference.
In the episode entitled "Edited", I can't find anything that explains the relationship of Talia & Gil.
yeah well, i've only seen the Edited episode once
so i'd definately have to rewatch it to be able to be of more help
but i agree that it all is very vague
but then again, all the motives and relationships in both Seed and Destiny were pretty much vague
and only some were explained in the last few episodes of Seed, which was too much of a rush job anyways [img]i/expressions/rolleye.gif[/img]
Love is fiction, misery is my only friend
that's because i was wrong, the episode that shows Dullindal and Talia "breaking up" is the episode called FatesOriginally posted by: Terracosmo
If you by Edited mean the episode where Gil has his flashbacks about Talia, then that's the one I'm using as reference.
In the episode entitled "Edited", I can't find anything that explains the relationship of Talia & Gil.
the Dullindal/Rau chessboard episode, and yes it isn't clearly explained, just that Talia can no longer be with Gil because she wants to have kids
but there are alot of things that need explaining in Destiny, even some things that linger from Seed
i doubt we get all the answers we want though[img]i/expressions/rolleye.gif[/img]
Love is fiction, misery is my only friend
Dullindal wanted to fulfill his life goal and Talia wanted to have a baby therefore she couldn't be with him anymore and didn't want to since he wouldn't supply here with the necessary equioment to make a baby. It's like "If he wanted a baby we could stay together". it's all a matter of what she wants the most, Gil or a baby. Decisions, decisions, decisions.
I still find it strange that she joined Gil's cause all of a sudden.
There are some strict laws in PLANT about having kids. There may have been something preventing them from having a kid together.Originally posted by: PSJ
Dullindal wanted to fulfill his life goal and Talia wanted to have a baby therefore she couldn't be with him anymore and didn't want to since he wouldn't supply here with the necessary equioment to make a baby. It's like "If he wanted a baby we could stay together". it's all a matter of what she wants the most, Gil or a baby. Decisions, decisions, decisions.
I still find it strange that she joined Gil's cause all of a sudden.
Well...don't coordinators have fertility problems in general? Maybe Gil is infertile and that's why Talia left him.
Does anyone knows what happened or who is was with Talia in Phase 29 when she dumped him?.
That's what we want to know.
Edit: My theory is that she fell in love with Rau and had Rey. Then Rau died and Talia decided to rejoin ZAFT to be close to her son Rey, and the latter doesn't know that Talia is his mother. Of course, all of this is more or less impossible, but I'd love that...
I agree with PSJ, She left the Chairman cause she wanted to start a family, that's it. It happens alot in the workplace and stuff, the chairman wanted her to stay with him to fulfill his goals....
niiice. I really like that theory. That would be an awesome twist.Originally posted by: Terracosmo
That's what we want to know.
Edit: My theory is that she fell in love with Rau and had Rey. Then Rau died and Talia decided to rejoin ZAFT to be close to her son Rey, and the latter doesn't know that Talia is his mother. Of course, all of this is more or less impossible, but I'd love that...
@kovash
i think you are getting a little too sentimental. As forum rules state, a little profanity is acceptable but excessive is forbidden. And besides i dont think bs really counts for being anything. Also you can't use the argument of talia and rey having similar features to relate them. Tonnes of anime characters all look the same. After all, Meer and Azrael have the same face, and i dont think they are related
I figured it out since we're saying who r Rey's parents, it must be Djibril and the Chairman, no doubt in my mind. Look at the features, all you need is some purple lip stick for Rey! Bingo, mystery solved, OH YA!
No...Luna is whisper to Shinn saying lets...Fc*k....
Stella has a mind of a 10 year old and look at her...he is all boney and sh*t, i rather go with Luna...Smart and normal.... someone that could have a good conversation with...
Posting Permissions
ChaosK 
