Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 20 of 25

Thread: Manga Poll

  1. #1

    Manga Poll

    Since its impossible to pick the GREATEST MANGA OF THEM ALL!, I decided that having a poll on the best manga by category would be the most accurate way to figure out the best manga. If you don't understand my logic, picture this: The best manga in your favorite category could be, in your mind, the best manga.

    But enough about that. I'll list some general categories, then you vote. If anyone has any other categories, just mention them and I'll edit this post.

    Rules:
    1. Try to answer every category.
    2. Only list one unless its absolutely necessary.
    3. No anime.

    CATEGORIES:
    Most realistic manga (aka, most likely to take place in real life)

    Most detailed manga

    Best mystery manga

    Funniest manga

    Most violent manga

    Most action-y

    Best sci-fi manga

    Best historical manga (aka, takes place in medieval times, ancient rome, etc)

    Best world

    Most twisted storyline

    Most pointless

    Best romance manga

    Saddest storyline

    Most disturbing

    Most religious

    Most racist

    Most nudity without being hentai

    Best character (list character and manga)

    Hottest character (list character and manga)

    Best use of ninjas ([img]i/expressions/face-icon-small-tongue.gif[/img])

    New categories:
    Best Martial arts

    Best Samurai

    Best Shonen or Youth manga

    Most unpredictable Storyline


    Best real sport:

    Best 'I can't believe they made this into a manga' sport:

    Best high school Romance:

    Best highschool adventure:

    Best musical story:

  2. #2
    Sexfiend Terracosmo's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2003
    Location
    Outside you, inside you, does it matter?
    Age
    38
    Posts
    7,218

    Manga Poll

    The answer to all your categories is: JoJo's Bizarre Adventure.

  3. #3
    Ciber's Minion Mut's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2003
    Location
    LA, Cali
    Age
    40
    Posts
    4,086

    Manga Poll

    Originally posted by: BravoSector
    Since its impossible to pick the GREATEST MANGA OF THEM ALL!, I decided that having a poll on the best manga by category would be the most accurate way to figure out the best manga. If you don't understand my logic, picture this: The best manga in your favorite category could be, in your mind, the best manga.

    But enough about that. I'll list some general categories, then you vote. If anyone has any other categories, just mention them and I'll edit this post.

    Rules:
    1. Try to answer every category.
    2. Only list one unless its absolutely necessary.
    3. No anime.

    CATEGORIES:
    Most realistic manga (aka, most likely to take place in real life)
    Beck

    Most detailed manga
    Berserk

    Best mystery manga
    Berserk (mystery as in like detective shit?)

    Funniest manga
    One Piece (would be FMP: Fumoffu but I think it's in anime form only)

    Most violent manga
    Berserk

    Most action-y
    Berserk

    Best sci-fi manga
    Berserk

    Best historical manga (aka, takes place in medieval times, ancient rome, etc)
    Berserk

    Best world
    Berserk

    Most twisted storyline
    Berserk

    Most pointless
    I don't read pointless manga

    Best romance manga
    I don't read romance manga

    Saddest storyline
    Berserk

    Most disturbing
    Berserk

    Most religious
    FMA

    Most racist
    Berserk (the tiny bit of racism [slavery] is all the racism I've seen in any manga)

    Most nudity without being hentai
    Berserk

    Best character (list character and manga)
    Gatts from Berserk

    Hottest character (list character and manga)
    Chidori from FMP

    Best use of ninjas
    Naruto
    www.rolleyes.net/

    Financial aspect of my life is revealed.

  4. #4

    Manga Poll

    Look at Mut's answers!
    but with romance manga, Ichigo 100% - Ah! My Goddess

  5. #5
    Ciber's Minion Mut's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2003
    Location
    LA, Cali
    Age
    40
    Posts
    4,086

    Manga Poll

    Oh fuck, I do read romance manga.

    That would be, Ah! My Goddess.
    www.rolleyes.net/

    Financial aspect of my life is revealed.

  6. #6
    Jounin Winged Dancer's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2003
    Location
    誰も知らない屋の裏
    Age
    39
    Posts
    898

    Manga Poll

    Ichigo 100% is not romance manga, is "Fanservice with a ball-less main character manga". I'll do the poll later.

    無理してここまでやってきて これからもすっと同じだろう
    それでも何かを信じたい 心の奥の声

  7. #7

    Manga Poll

    I like this thread cause the catogaries are very good.

    You can add these to the list: Best Martial arts,Best Samurai,Best Shonen or Youth manga and most importantly: Most unpredictable Storyline

    Most realistic manga

    Hajime No Ippo cause the characters and their world are so real.


    Most detailed manga

    Hajime No Ippo

    Best mystery manga

    The Death Note

    Funniest Manga

    Hajime No Ippo

    Most violent manga

    Berserk

    Most action-y

    Berserk

    Best sci-fi manga

    Battle Angel Alita

    Best historical manga

    The Ravages of Time(its about the Three Kingdoms and it feels so much like how China was back then.)

    Best world

    Hajime No Ippo

    Most twisted storyline

    Berserk

    Most pointless

    I dont read pointless mangas

    Saddest storyline

    Lone Wolf and Cub

    Most disturbing

    Berserk


    Best romance manga

    I havent read one

    Most religious

    FMA


    Most racist

    Hajime No Ippo (i havent seen much racism in mangas. The most racism i have seen is when Miyata loses a game he won clearly just cause he was from a japan and when Volg got dropped by his club despite winning couple of matches cause he was from another country)

    Most nudity without being hentai

    GANTZ

    Best character

    Takamura from Hajime No Ippo,Guts from Berserk

    Hottest character

    Slan The God Hand from Berserk

    Best use of ninjas

    Basilisk

    Its just as i thought Hajime No Ippo and Berserk each top 6 catogaries.

  8. #8

    Manga Poll

    Hakeem: New categories added except for Most unpredictable story, since its covered by Most twisted story. (Probably)

    I didn't do this yet, so here goes:

    Most realistic manga (aka, most likely to take place in real life)
    Parallel (No magic or anything unusual at all)

    Most detailed manga
    Battle Angel Alita

    Best mystery manga
    Death Note

    Funniest manga
    Pretty Face

    Most violent manga
    Gantz

    Most action-y
    DBZ

    Best sci-fi manga
    Battle Angel Alita

    Best historical manga (aka, takes place in medieval times, ancient rome, etc)
    Houshin Engi

    Best world
    Battle Angel Alita

    Most twisted storyline
    Gantz

    Most pointless
    Oh! My Goddess (I quit after the 5th volume since I found it so boring, but if you can, prove me wrong.)

    Best romance manga
    Love Hina (I've only read 2 romance mangas, this was the better)

    Saddest storyline
    Battle Angel Alita

    Most disturbing
    Gantz

    Most religious
    Never read one

    Most racist
    Never read one

    Most nudity without being hentai
    Gantz

    Best character (list character and manga)
    I'll get back to this, but for now, I'll put Desty Nova from Battle Angel Alita

    Hottest character (list character and manga)
    Dakki from Houshin Engi

    Best use of ninjas
    Naruto (only ninja manga I've ever read)

  9. #9

    Manga Poll

    Most Twisted storyline and unpredtictale storyline isnt the same thing. For example Berserk has twisted storyline but there are mangas who have more unpredictable storyline line then Berserk,like FMA,The Death Note etc.

    Best Martial Arts

    Shura No Mon

    Best Samurai

    Lone Wolf and Cub

    Best Shonen

    Full Metal Alchemist

  10. #10

    Manga Poll

    Most realistic manga (aka, most likely to take place in real life)
    Hajime no Ippo

    Most detailed manga
    Hajime no Ippo

    Best mystery manga
    Gantz

    Funniest manga
    One Piece

    Most violent manga
    Gantz

    Most action-y
    Gantz

    Best sci-fi manga
    Gantz

    Best historical manga (aka, takes place in medieval times, ancient rome, etc)
    Rurouni Kenshin

    Best world
    One Piece

    Most twisted storyline
    Gantz

    Most pointless
    don't read pointless manga's

    Best romance manga
    no romance either

    Saddest storyline
    don't know

    Most disturbing
    Gantz

    Most religious
    FMA

    Most racist
    Hajime no Ippo

    Most nudity without being hentai
    Gantz

    Best character (list character and manga)
    Takamura Hajime no Ippo

    Hottest character (list character and manga)
    Hitsugaya's Vice Captain Bleach

    Best use of ninjas
    Naruto

    Best Martial arts
    don't know

    Best Samurai
    Rurouni Kenshin

    Best Shonen or Youth manga
    Bleach

  11. #11

    Manga Poll

    Alright Hakeem, you win. I'll add it.

    Best Martial arts
    DBZ

    Best Samurai
    Never read any.

    Best Shonen or Youth manga
    Bleach

    Most unpredictable Storyline
    Gantz

  12. #12
    Procacious Polymath Ryllharu's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2004
    Location
    American Empire
    Age
    40
    Posts
    9,936

    Manga Poll

    Most realistic manga (aka, most likely to take place in real life)
    Beck

    Most detailed manga
    Berserk

    Best mystery manga
    Death Note

    Funniest manga
    Yakitate! Japan

    Most violent manga
    Berserk

    Most action-y
    Flame of Recca

    Best sci-fi manga
    Ghost in the Shell Man-Machine Interface

    Best historical manga (aka, takes place in medieval times, ancient rome, etc)
    Shinsengumi Imon Peace Maker and PeaceMaker Kurogane (sequel)

    Best world
    Air Gear

    Most twisted storyline
    Gantz

    Most pointless
    Orefeti

    Best romance manga
    Kare Kano

    Saddest storyline
    Full Moon wo Sagashite

    Most disturbing
    Gantz

    Most religious
    Berserk

    Most racist
    never really noticed anything, other than stardard "americans are drunks and loud"

    Most nudity without being hentai
    Gantz

    Best character (list character and manga)
    Gatts (Berserk)

    Hottest character (list character and manga)
    Noyamano Ringo (Air Gear)

    Best use of ninjas
    Shinsengumi Imon Peace Maker and PeaceMaker Kurogane (sequel)
    actually realistic!

    Best Samurai
    Shinsengumi Imon Peace Maker and PeaceMaker Kurogane (sequel)

    Best Shonen or Youth manga
    Bleach

    Most unpredictable Storyline
    Death Note

  13. #13
    Sexfiend Terracosmo's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2003
    Location
    Outside you, inside you, does it matter?
    Age
    38
    Posts
    7,218

    Manga Poll

    I can't believe you listed Peacemaker Kurogane as "best" something. That's the worst show ever made. : (

  14. #14
    Procacious Polymath Ryllharu's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2004
    Location
    American Empire
    Age
    40
    Posts
    9,936

    Manga Poll

    Manga, not series. We are in the manga forum. And the manga is SOOOO much better than the show, which is pretty bad (except for that one eps).

    Comparatively, the show was downright godawful.

  15. #15

    Manga Poll

    Is the manga of peace maker that good? Is there good fights in it?

  16. #16
    Procacious Polymath Ryllharu's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2004
    Location
    American Empire
    Age
    40
    Posts
    9,936

    Manga Poll

    The fights are short but they get the job done (like most manga). The art is much better than the show and the story actually progresses.

    The show ends by mixing the two series together and hashing out some bullsh*t ending. Shinsengumi Imon is the basic plot of the show while PMK is what happens after the show ends with most of the lame ghost stuff, though the rest of it is really good.

    I'll stop here because I really don't want to derail this topic too far.

  17. #17

    Manga Poll

    I got some of the manga for that, and it was pretty good, what I've read.

  18. #18

    Manga Poll

    CATEGORIES:
    Most realistic manga (aka, most likely to take place in real life)
    Beck

    Most detailed manga
    20th Century Boys

    Best mystery manga
    20th Century Boys

    Funniest manga
    One Piece and Hajime no Ippo

    Most violent manga
    3x3 Eyes

    Most action-y
    Berserk

    Best sci-fi manga
    Agharta only one i've read

    Best historical manga (aka, takes place in medieval times, ancient rome, etc)
    Vagabond

    Best world
    Hunter X Hunter

    Most twisted storyline
    Berserk

    Most pointless
    I don't read pointless manga

    Best romance manga
    Ichigo 100% and Ah! My Goddess

    Saddest storyline
    Deep Love Ayu

    Most disturbing
    Berserk

    Most religious
    D.Gray-Man

    Most racist

    I'm not in the lookout for this shit, so I don't know

    Most nudity without being hentai
    Berserk [Though it in the border of being hentai, the fucked up kind of hentai]

    Best character (list character and manga)
    Gon from Hunter X Hunter

    Hottest character (list character and manga)
    Urd in Ah! My Goddess, and all the girls in Ichigo 100%

    Best use of ninjas
    Blade of the Immortal

    Best Martial Arts
    Shura no Mon

    Best Shounen
    One Piece and Bleach

    Best Samurai
    Blade of the Immortal

    Most Unpredictable Storyline
    20th Century Boys and Death Note

  19. #19
    Jounin Honoko's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2005
    Location
    New York
    Posts
    964

    Manga Poll

    i don't read as much manga as some of u guys... so i just filled the in categories i could answer =P

    Most realistic manga (aka, most likely to take place in real life)
    Confessions

    Most detailed manga
    Hajime no Ippo

    Funniest manga
    Azumanga Daioh

    Most action-y
    errr.... Bleach? (i suck at this list)

    Best sci-fi manga
    Cowboy Bebop

    Best historical manga (aka, takes place in medieval times, ancient rome, etc)
    Lone Wolf and Cub

    Best world
    One Piece

    Most twisted storyline
    Homunculus

    Most disturbing
    Homunculus

    Most religious
    Evangelion

    Most racist
    too vague-- i could claim any manga that mentions WWII and treats japan as a victim would be racist since it ignores all the atrocities the country committed before their defeat =P fortunately for me, my brain tends to glaze over those parts and keep reading.

    Best character (list character and manga)
    Ichigo, Bleach

    Hottest character (list character and manga)
    errr... ???

    Best use of ninjas
    Naruto

    Best Samurai
    Kenshin

    Best Shonen or Youth manga
    Bleach

  20. #20
    not over yet Death BOO Z's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2003
    Location
    Israel
    Age
    37
    Posts
    4,336

    Manga Poll

    Ohy vey, enough categories to make me go Yiddish.

    CATEGORIES:
    Most realistic manga (aka, most likely to take place in real life)
    Living Game

    Most detailed manga
    I don't understand this one

    Best mystery manga
    Monster

    Funniest manga
    Yakitate Japan

    Most violent manga
    Hokuto no Ken

    Most action-y
    Hajime no Ippo

    Best sci-fi manga
    Battle royale counts? if not, then i'll go for the only sci-fi I remember reading -Stellvia of the universe

    Best historical manga (aka, takes place in medieval times, ancient rome, etc)
    Berserk

    Best world
    Berserk

    Most twisted storyline
    Jisatsu Circle

    Most pointless
    Saigake! Cromatie high

    Best romance manga
    Kare Kano

    Saddest storyline
    Real, just becaues you know they'll always be crippeled

    Most disturbing
    Shadow Star

    Most religious
    Evanegelion, just for the heck of it

    Most nudity without being hentai
    Gantz

    Best character (list character and manga)
    Gutts, Berserk

    Hottest character (list character and manga)
    Lilim, Lilim Kiss (heck, it changes every week or so, even more often)

    Best use of ninjas ()
    Screw this category, i'm not putting Naruto in here, no way

    New categories:
    Best Samurai
    Vegabond

    Best Shonen or Youth manga
    Dragon Ball Z

    Most unpredictable Storyline
    Death Note


    of course, my favorites are still the same, (HNI, KKNJ, Gantz, Trigun and Berserk) but it's a nice list of animes to read... (mega lie - I won't read any manga in the next few years, except for my usless atempts of keeping in touch on the big names)

    new categories should be:

    Best real sport:
    Hajime no Ippo or Slam Dunk

    Best 'I can't believe they made this into a manga' sport:
    Break Shot

    Best high school Romance:
    Kare Kano

    Best highschool adventure:
    Harulaye II boy

    Best musical story:
    Bremen

    sig made by Itachi-y2k5, thanks, dude!
    Currently Watching: probably a show directed at 9 years old girls, lets be honest.

    You know the important distinction between Batman and me? Batman is fictional. In real life, there isn't always an alternative.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •