i actually liked this movie alot. before taking my seat i was sceptical and thought, well i gotta see this one anyway. but when i got up from my seat it was a diffrent story.

first of all i think this movie really made Vader the best character in all the movies, the others are either completly good or bad. in this one vader seems something in between.

As for the scenes with portman and christensen(sp?) its clearly the sucky dialog, lucas can't write a dialog between two people that love each other appearently. The first time i noticed was the first scene at the balcony between portman and christensen. it just plain sucked, who would talk like that? there were some other bits here and there that sounded really bad to. I felt that christensen was the perfect choice for anakin, he seemed so evil yet wanted to help the people he loved at all cost, and he wasnt a whiny pussy like he was in ep II. I loved the scene where Vader screams, it marks the end to anakin and the begining of vader, the transformation is complete.

One thing that bothered me tho was how easy all the jedi's was shot down, especially the council members should be able to do a little more than get suprised when they get a shot in the neck. windu went down pretty fast to, it felt a little rushed at the end when they had to close it up. ewan mcgregor did a good job in this one, he got closer to how alec guiness handled the role in the old movies.

am i the only one who reacted at the clone guys name? cody? wtf is that? i just cant take that name seriously.

all in all i think it was a great movie and it tied the lose strings up pretty good. i would like to see re-makes on the old movies for some reason, with new actors and fixed enviroments and such. i just dont like hamill as luke and carrie fisher as leia.