Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood

new OP and ED... neither are memorable at all... I'll miss the first OP.

Scar, what a hilarious rag-tag team he has with him now. May will surely pull her weight, considering she can heal wounds. I thought the last scene with Yoki asking Scar about his name was the most interesting, non-comical moment in the episode.

The best moment? Barry's love at twelfth bullet for Hawkeye. She's so cool. Runner up was the quick cut with Winry suddenly working on Ed's arm and the bloody wrench lying in the corner.

The action was good, but nothing incredible like in 14. I thought they shoved a bit too much of the concepts about Eastern alchemy at us. Did a great job bringing in the new characters and making them all pretty interesting. I'm interested to see how they handle the pacing from here on out. It'll have to move fast, but I hope they don't make it too much so.

Ahaa.. I thought he was going to sneakily kill the panda..

Yeah, I thought he thought it was another alchemical chimera since the panda seems...I dunno, humanish in demeanor. And he was about to blow that shit up.

You all are weird people....

Gotwoot is thirsty for blood apparently

I don't think people were unjustified thinking that. Scar killed almost every Alchemist he's met in the series. I don't know why people think its weird he might try and kill this alchemist and her little familiar.

This scar isn't like the old one, he doesn't think alchemists are evil

He only goes after the ones who were involved with the destruction of his homeland ( i think... )

[Eclipse] Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood - 16 - HD | SD

Yes, Scar isn't a homicidal psychopath who kills any alchemists he encounters. Originally Scar was simply out to get revenge against those who were responsible for the slaughter of his people but now Scar intends to judge anyone who goes against God.

He killed Tucker because he used his wife and his daughter as raw materials to create a chimera, and Nina was a mercy killing. All the other Alchemist he killed were directly involved in the Ishval massacre and he intends to kill Ed because Ed attempted human transmutation.

No, because he's a state alchemist.

Again, i think you're confusing his motives from the first season with this one

oooh new ep!

Yeah you're right he does want to kill him because he is a state alchemist but he does want to kill state alchemists because he believes they go against God.

Winry's tears make me cry too!

A fairly moving episode. There wasn't a whole lot else to say about it, since it was largely a conclusion to Hughes' death, and a set up episode. It was obvious who the guy's girlfriend was as soon as Lust said she had a date. No shocker there, she's got that name for a reason.

I'd hit it.

Anyway, yeah, was a pretty sad ep, except for that prince and his fainting problem ;P

And hence he's got no reason to kill the girl who just healed him.

Or her panda.

http://www.animefreak.tv/watch/fullm...sode-16-online

Been catching them online.

Scar's a bad guy. He can kill people without much of a reason. He wouldn't be much of a villain otherwise.

Let's not start labeling people yet Kraco

The original FMA is in my top 3 series of all time. I thought it was so well done and really liked how it came to an end. Even the movie was good and broke from the usual naruto type filler movies.

I didn't know what to think when I heard that they were remaking it... but it is really good !

So here is the reason for this thread... If they keep it up and this 2009 version is just amazing, what happens next? if you were trying to suggest an anime series to somebody would you be like... FMA!... but watch the 2nd version?

I just think the first go around was so good, and if this 2009 remake is amazing also, which one will survive?

Survive? Why would anyone have to choose between the 2? Why not just watch both?