PDA

View Full Version : GW Reading the Same Manga Part 6



Munsu
Mon, 02-13-2006, 09:20 AM
Info on what we are trying to do can be found in this thread:
http://forums.gotwoot.net/mess...6201&enterthread=y (http://forums.gotwoot.net/messageview.cfm?catid=33&threadid=16201&enterthrea d=y)


Here are the winners and the participating series we have up till now...

Round One Winner: Air Gear
Round Two Winners: Priest and Jiraishin
Round Three Winners: Ares and Tokko
Round Four Winners: Shamo and Leviathan
Round Five Winners: Eden and MPD Psycho

<u>Poll #5 Begins Now</u>[/b]
MAKE SURE YOU VOTE IN THE FIRST POLL BEFORE THE SECOND POLL!!!!


Here are the manga choices:

Shamo (http://www.manga.baka-updates.com/series.html?id=325) = Winner of Poll #4

Parasyte (http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/manga.php?id=1570)

Dangu (http://www.manga.baka-updates.com/series.html?id=1276)

Change Guy (http://www.manga.baka-updates.com/series.html?id=258)

Air Gear (http://manganews.net/seriesinfo.php?id=883) = Winner of Poll #1

Addicted to Curry (http://www.manga.baka-updates.com/series.html?id=94)

666 Satan (http://www.manga.baka-updates.com/series.html?id=135)

Togari (http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/manga.php?id=5308)

Team Medical Dragon (http://www.manga.baka-updates.com/series.html?id=718)

Gekkoh (http://www.manga.baka-updates.com/series.html?id=437)

Otogi Matsuri (http://www.manga.baka-updates.com/series.html?id=40)

Freesia (http://omanga.net/?cid=b_freesia)

Leviathan (http://omanga.net/?cid=b_leviathan) = Winner of Poll #4

Jiraishin (http://www.manga.baka-updates.com/series.html?id=156) = Winner of Poll #2

Tokko (http://www.animewaves.net/index.php?goto=m-tokko) = Winner of Poll #3

Onikiri Jyuzo (http://www.manga.baka-updates.com/series.html?id=1445)

Chaosic Rune (http://www.manga.baka-updates.com/series.html?id=673)

MPD Psycho (http://omanga.net/?cid=b_mpd_psycho) = Winner of Poll #5

Priest (http://www.icomics.com/rev_031703_priest.shtml) = Winner of Poll #2

Vagabond (http://www.manga.baka-updates.com/series.html?id=387)

Homunculus (http://www.manga.baka-updates.com/series.html?id=1525)

Eden (http://www.manga.baka-updates.com/series.html?id=930) = Winner of Poll #5

Ares (http://www.manga.baka-updates.com/series.html?id=688) = Winner of Poll #3



When you vote, please post an explanation on your choice to so that we can understand your reasoning of your choice...

Also, make sure to give more suggestions if you want... I'll add those suggestions when we do the next poll after a winner has been chosen...

New series added: No new series added

Ryllharu
Mon, 02-13-2006, 10:58 AM
Gekkoh sounded good because I really enjoy yakuza manga/anime.

I'll still be clinging to the idea to start Addicted to Curry.

Munsu
Mon, 02-13-2006, 11:03 AM
Lol, you guys really want Addicted to Curry... But I don't want to let that happen... yet...

So, my first vote went to Otogi Matsuri...

I read what has been released a couple of days ago, and the art was simply amazing, plus the last couple of chaters were pretty good... Action has been improving chapter after chapter, and they don't shy away from showing some gore...


Second vote went for Vagabond...

Come on, everyone wants to read some Musashi...

rockmanj
Mon, 02-13-2006, 11:44 AM
i think we all know y i voted for 'addicted'. ??????In fact, if u voted for it, check out the topic i created!!

Munsu
Mon, 02-13-2006, 02:10 PM
I'm a bit dissapointed... some people keep voting, but once a new series begins no one discusses it... For example, Shamo and Leviathan have 0 discussion, and they are for the most part pretty good, especially Shamo... You don't have to read the whole thing, just read a couple of chapters and post some impressions...

Ryllharu
Mon, 02-13-2006, 06:07 PM
Well, Ares got a fair amount of discussion out of it, as did Air Gear and Tokko. As for the rest, I don't know, a lot of them failed to catch my interest.

I'm going to keep voting for Curry because Yui is probably the most natural looking heroine in the 95+ series I read. (Well, its mostly because of the chapter where she's wearing the sari.) She's not overly well endowed (Ichigo 100%, Air Gear, you name it), and you could really see her as someone who actually exists.

Munsu
Mon, 02-13-2006, 10:34 PM
Yeah, I see what you mean...

But it's not much to ask to download a couple of chapters of a manga that "we" chose and see if you could at least like it, and if you don't then simply drop it... All I'm asking is for your impressions on the manga from what you read, if not this whole thing we are doing is meaningless... Which at the moment, it kind of is...