Which group do you prefer?

[Roko]

I'm just curious to what you all think (okay, fine, maybe I did steal this topic from narutofan, but I still wanna know which and why you prefer one group over another). For myself, I cannot decide. I think Inane has better cleaning, but Shannaro has better translations. What do you think?

[Mut]

Shannaro for speed scanslation. Inane for keeps.

You can't beat Inane's editing. They just have way more experience.

[Assertn]

their translations are almost always shaky though

[Y]

Whoever has the better raw and editing (Inane). I just make up dialogue in my head that sounds better than Inane anyway.

[Psyke]

It doesn't really matter to me, as long as it's fast.

[Shin_Naruto]

Inane had a few bad grammer oops' recently....

Im leaning more Shannaro

[SK]

inane

[Dezalanel]

I get shannaro first and then replace it when Inane comes out.

[kAi]

I read it like this
Raw > Shannaro > Inane

i keep the Inane

[Assertn]

actually i......go through both inane and shannaro's, and mix and match their pages based on which one translated/cleaned that page better

[kaigan]

no one can beat inane on editing, it's what they do. so like most of u, i read the shannaro but in the end, i keep inane due to the fact that i have all their works on naruto and don't want to change.

[Zhan]

Shannaro. I personally don't like Inane that much.

[Deblas]

For now Inane. I read shannaro scanlations cause its a speed sub. They even say its low quality. But still I haven't compared their high quality subs with Inane.

[sangai]

inane fan always..i will always download inane and keep theres..shannaro is good for the quick fix..but sometimes there translations arn't to my likings and inane just has a better translation over all...ima take the quality over the um uh..err speed.

[ChaosK]

Originally posted by: kAi
I read it like this
Raw > Shannaro > Inane

i keep the Inane

exactly how i do it except i can really read the raw, i forget where to get inane subs though.....so recentally its all been shannaro

[jing]

inane, good trasnlations, colour pages, good editing.

[Terracosmo]

Originally posted by: AssertnFailure
actually i......go through both inane and shannaro's, and mix and match their pages based on which one translated/cleaned that page better

Jesus, you're sick.

Myself I keep the one which comes first either Shannaro HQ or Inane.

[kAi]

Originally posted by: Chaoskiddo


Originally posted by: kAi
I read it like this
Raw > Shannaro > Inane

i keep the Inane

exactly how i do it except i can really read the raw, i forget where to get inane subs though.....so recentally its all been shannaro

Inane's version can be gotten from their IRC channel
#mangareaders @ irc.irchighway.net
and various other places, I'm pretty sure narutofan do.

[samsonlonghair]

Sometimes I think that Inane takes themselves too seriously, but I suppose that's their right. They've been fansubbing Naruto for sometime now -- ever since Toryiama's World quit and NULL scanslations dropped out. I remember that Inane used to work in conjunction with NULL, but since going on without NULL, Inane's work has gotten much better.

[PSJ]

while shannaro's scan was very good i still go with inane, you just cant beat inane. i didnt feel like shannaros translations were good either, i guess i need to wait and check out inane's to see which sounds better tho.

[Assertn]

Originally posted by: Terracosmo


Originally posted by: AssertnFailure
actually i......go through both inane and shannaro's, and mix and match their pages based on which one translated/cleaned that page better

Jesus, you're sick.

Myself I keep the one which comes first either Shannaro HQ or Inane.

haha, well what can i say?
with inane alot of times it'll be hit or miss on a page-by-page basis...
so i just make sure not to keep the misses

[ChaosK]

that would take a LOT of time...

[2:25]

I read both and I've noticed a few slip ups here and there, so they're equal to me.

[ChaosK]

well i cant read japanese so i really wouldnt know the difference, i just say inane because they're editing looks better.

[kimbap629]

Inane is the AonE or Naruto anime. Althought both AonE and Inane do not release as fast as other groups, it's worth waiting because of the high quality in both looks and translation.

So, I prefer to wait for Inane. The wait just makes reading the manga or watching the anime sooo much more exciting.

[Prof. Chaos]

It's not just the translation but how clean they get the pages to be.

[Kenshiro]

Didnt Inane fuck up and overedit a page to make the leader of akatsuki have mangekyou eyes?

[Assertn]

for anyone who thinks that inane's releases are more refined and cleaner......
i suggest you check out shannaro's HQ 257 release

not only is the image quality equal to that of inane's, but the translations are far more accurate as well
they even have better colored pages than inane, AND they throw in extra pages to identify interesting details that we otherwise wouldnt catch with inane's

[kAi]

I'll stick with Inane thanks, Shannaro just try to hard to be Inane, I rather the way Inane has translated, and the way they convey it.

[Shin_Naruto]

Originally posted by: AssertnFailure
for anyone who thinks that inane's releases are more refined and cleaner......
i suggest you check out shannaro's HQ 257 release

You can lead a horse to water...


Im with ya Assert.

[Assertn]

Originally posted by: kAi
I'll stick with Inane thanks, Shannaro just try to hard to be Inane, I rather the way Inane has translated, and the way they convey it.

"Well! Last time i was unprepared, but I'm not like that this time. This won't go the same way as it did last time..." - INANE TRANSLATION OF KAKASHI

i agree....inane's extensive vocabulary for conveying dialogue sure is astounding

who cares how hard shannaro tries? the more effort they put towards their work, the happier i'll be

[kAi]

And Shannaro don't do the same?

[Assertn]

nope....i havent found any dialogue translated from shannaro that makes me think "wow, that sounded weird/redundant/stupid"

[weakest anbu]

I like shannaro's (LQ) version. Fast, good quality, translates everything (sidebars, title page etc.) and little to none translation error.

[Hakeem_21]

I dont save the chaps so i download shannaro LQ and HQ ,i got tired of Inane long time since they got slow and they have been sloppy with the translation just before they got slow anyway.

[RyougaZell]

Shannaro all the way.
Inane's translations are evil... and they even dared to add a Sharingan to akatsuki's leader.

[Mut]

Originally posted by: RyougaZell
Shannaro all the way.
Inane's translations are evil... and they even dared to add a Sharingan to akatsuki's leader.
They acknowledged their fuck up and added a re-edited page from that chapter in one of their releases.

[RasenDori]

still... the fact that they would take it upon themselves and add something that wasnt there and would only serve to make people ask questions and cause controversy is just plan... well... irrosponsible.

[Hakeem_21]

Who do they think they are to change the mangakas work......